Wednesday, 16 May 2012

Iran: Pinkwashing's Flipside

A story by Dan Littauer claiming four men in Iran had been sentenced to death for "sodomy" has been published by four British gay news sites; Gay Middle East, Gay Star News, LGBTQNation, and Pink News.
In the last few years, a number of stories about men being executed in Iran "just for being gay" have been found not to have happened, or to have no evidence to back the story up.
Because of their emotional potency, they are used for propaganda purposes by the Right about an Officially Declared Enemy of the US - the modern equivalent to First World War horror stories about German soldiers bouncing babies on their bayonets. 
It's the flipside to pinkwashing of Israel.
Scott Long, former LGBT director at Human Rights Watch, asks how sure we can be this time

"You can say anything you want because you support power, and nobody expects you to justify anything. For example, on the unimaginable circumstance that I was on, say, Nightline, and I was asked, say, "Do you think Kadhafi is a terrorist?" I could say, "Yeah, Kadhafi is a terrorist." I don't need any evidence. Suppose I said, "George Bush is a terrorist." Well, then I would be expected to provide evidence, "Why would you say that?""

Noam Chomsky, 2002 interview

Update: There are some very interesting interviews with LGBT Iranians in LGBT Republic Of Iran by Small Media - which contradict the line that men are regularly executed for being gay and/or having gay sex).

4 comments:

  1. Demonize the 'perception' of the 'enemy' psychology 101! But ...are you pro-death penality ... Richard?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am against the death penalty.
    I'm one of those funny people that's against killing people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was hoping you'd post about this, Fagburn.
    Thanks for the link to the Scott Long piece, too.

    x

    ReplyDelete
  4. You're misreporting Dan Littauer's story, which is a straightforward report and at no point says the men are gay.

    If anyone reports on any aspect of life for gays in Iran, or treatment of dissidents for that matter, are they automatically part of the Western war machine? Are those seeking asylum in the West just making it all up and should be put on the next plane back?

    Maybe you should ask why it took until Scott Long left HRW before they published a report on the situation of gays in Iran.

    ReplyDelete