Saturday 20 October 2012

Noam Chomsky: First, Do No Harm



In the case of South Africa, for example, in which I was involved in the boycotts, they were highly selective and they were selected in a way which would lead to help for the victims, not to make us feel good, help for the victims. The same in the case of the Vietnam war, where I was involved, and I was imprisoned many times, I was involved in civil disobedience, organizing resistance and so on.
But we always had to ask ourselves, when we pick a certain tactic, what does it mean for the Vietnamese, not what does it mean for us? And sometimes there are things you should do and sometimes there are things you shouldn’t do, and in fact they were very helpful in that regard...

In the case of any tactic, you ask yourself, what are its consequences, ultimately for the victims, and indirectly for the audience you are trying to reach... That’s the question you ask when you carry out any tactic, whether it is disobedience, breaking bank windows, demonstrations, whatever it is. Those are the questions you ask if you care about the victims, if you don’t care about the victims, you won’t bother with these questions and you just do what makes you feel good...

Noam Chomsky interviewed by Electronic Intifada on an academic boycott of Israel.

What he says also rings true about much Western gay campaigning on issues in Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Africa and Asia.
It's usually "We must do something!" solipsistic, patronising, Orientalist, feel-good a/politics, with no thought about the consequences - which are often negative - for the people they're supposedly trying to help.
See All Out, Kaleidoscope Trust, Saint Tatchell et al.

PS The phrase "First, do no harm", often quoted by Uncle Noam, comes from the Hippocratic oath. 

8 comments:

  1. Must look up this Hippocrates guy, he seems quite sensible.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Recipe for stagnation, there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's a little patronising to gay activists in those countries to say that without our "help" things will stagnate.

      Delete
  3. Recipe for thinking about consequences, sir.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You're overlooking a crucial distinction between "Western gay campaigning" and the movement for boycott, divestment and sanctions. In many places, there just isn't an indigenous constituency who wants what the gay internationalists are selling. However, Palestinians have specifically asked people in solidarity to build pressure on Israel using BDS tactics.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Fair point.

    Chomsky - not me - was only talking about the academic boycott, though...

    ReplyDelete