Tuesday, 13 May 2014

Ukip: Who Do You Think You Are Kidding, Mr Farage?


Homosexuality makes most people over 70 feel uncomfortable, according to Nigel Farage. The Ukip leader was attempting to defend Roger Helmer, his candidate in next month's Newark byelection, who had claimed that some older people found homosexuality "distasteful if not viscerally repugnant". (Others would say that this was a better description of Ukip itself.) Farage clearly feels not only the need to protect the rights of prejudiced people of every stripe but also entitled to speak on behalf of most older people. In fact he was simply enacting the latest variant of how many people can you fit into a Mini: how many stereotypes can you fit into Ukip?

As it happens, Farage is wrong about acceptance of homosexuality diminishing with age. A recent Pew Research Centre study found that, in the UK, 79% of 18- to 29-year-olds thought that homosexuality should be accepted, as did 82% of 30- to 49-year-olds and 71% of those in the 50-plus group. Unless the older figure conceals a sudden lurch towards disapproval on our 70th birthdays, acceptance in Britain remains relatively constant across the age bands. In other words, age doesn't seem to be a significant factor in shaping attitudes to homosexuality... *


George Montague, 90, at Brighton Pride.
I've just come from talking to a group of older women – g.o.d. (Growing Old Disgracefully), founded in 1993. I asked them for their reaction to Farage's comments. They were unanimous: don't characterise people on the basis of age. As one of them put it: "It's about closed minds. But minds don't necessarily close with age." Another balked at the idea that you should excuse prejudice on the grounds of age, suggesting that people should be prepared to take responsibility for their views at any age. A third felt patronised by Farage's comments, as though most old people were halfway to Alzheimer's – not that this would inevitably make them prejudiced.

One other fact doesn't seem to have occurred to Farage: that many over-70s are themselves gay...


The Guardian: 

Fagburn hasn't done any real research, but I bet you'd find homophobia makes more people over 70 uncomfortable.

* I know endless surveys have shown support for gay marriage shows a marked decline according to age, but that's not quite the same, so don't write in.

Update: The Britain of our youth was intolerant, now we find Farage intolerable Harry Leslie Smith, Guardian Cif.

But see comments for some of those pesky facts!

3 comments:

  1. If people in this country weren't so proud of their mathematical stupidity, then they might realise that if 50 - 70 year olds made up half the over 50 group and 80% accepted homosexuality, then only 62% of the over 70s accept it.

    Whilst Farage is wrong to claim most people over 70 are uncomfortable with homosexuality, people of that age reached adulthood before the 1967 Act. In my experience, many people over 70 do have more problems accepting it and to some extent its understandable. We are all products of our childhoods.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Unfortunately Anne Karpf is wrong about acceptance of homosexuality diminishing with age. The National Surveys of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles (Natsal) is a representative, household survey which recruited over 15,000 people in 2010-12. Results were published in the Lancet in December.

    They give figures on the proportion of people who think male-male sexual partnerships are "not wrong at all".

    Among men, 49% aged under 24 said, 50% aged 25-34, 46% aged 35-44, 38% aged 45-54, 33% aged 55-64, and 21% aged 65-74.

    Overall women are much more accepting but there's the same age relationship - 68% under 24 years said this, 67% aged 25-34, 64% aged 35-44, 60% aged 45-54, 52% aged 55-64 and 40% aged 65-74 years.

    People with more education, and people in managerial and professional occupations, tended to be more accepting.

    They've also run the surveys in 1990 and 2000, and attitudes have improved significantly over the years.

    Attitudes to female same-sex behaviour are similar.

    ReplyDelete